"I'll Venmo You Later"
Why it never happens
IOUs fade fast. Surveys suggest roughly 40 to 50%of informal loans to friends or family never get fully repaid, and "I'll get you next time" rarely fixes it.
The science of forgetting
In 1885, Hermann Ebbinghaus memorized lists of nonsense syllables and tested himself at increasing intervals to see how quickly they faded.
He tracked how quickly those lists faded. That pattern is now called the Ebbinghaus Forgetting Curve:
56%
forgotten within 1 hour
66%
forgotten within 24 hours
75%
forgotten within 6 days
79%
forgotten within 31 days
Most of the drop happens in the first few hours, then forgetting slows. By Sunday morning, the split you calculated at 9:47 PM on Saturday is already fuzzy. By next weekend, it is gone.
Restaurant checks blur together. Within a day, the exact items and amounts turn into "roughly $40, I think?"
Source: Memory: A Contribution to Experimental Psychology, Hermann Ebbinghaus, 1885
The IOU decay rate
People also remember they owe you and still do not pay. Behavioral economists have names for part of that pattern.
44%
of people who lent money to friends or family say they were never fully repaid
Source: FinanceBuzz survey of 1,000 U.S. adults, 2023
Hyperbolic discounting, documented by Laibson (1997), means the longer you wait, the less repayment feels worth doing. A $32 debt that felt urgent at the table feels trivial by tomorrow. Each day makes "I'll get you later" less likely to happen.
A Bankrate survey found 37% of respondents lost money after lending cash to a friend or family member.
Your brain hates future payments
Future payments feel less real than present ones, which is why "I'll deal with that later" is so easy to say even when you know you might not.
$100
today
feels like $100
$100
next week
feels like $85
$100
next month
feels like $60
When you agree to pay later, present-you gets relief from not paying. The version of you who has to send Venmo on Monday feels less and less like the person who ordered the second cocktail.
"We treat our future selves as strangers... we tend to give much less weight to the well-being of future selves than to the well-being of present selves."
Hal Hershfield, UCLA psychologist
The mental accounting loophole
Richard Thaler's work on mental accounting helps explain why friends treat IOUs differently from cash in the wallet:
- At the restaurant:The dinner exists in your "fun" or "social" budget. The money is already spent.
- At home:The IOU you owe exists in a vague "obligations" mental account. It doesn't feel like real money anymore.
Once a debt moves from "tonight's dinner" to a vague IOU, the urgency to repay drops fast. The money stops feeling like it left your pocket.
The social cost of asking twice
Asking someone to repay feels petty, even when the amount is real. The person who owes is mildly annoyed. The person who is owed is embarrassed to bring it up again.
Small debts often go unrecovered because eating the $27 hurts less than another awkward text.
$237
median amount that never gets paid back
26%
say it strained or ended a relationship
Sources: LendingTree and Bankrate lending surveys, 2023.
Settle at the table
Same night beats next week for both memory and motivation. Scan the receipt, assign items, and send payment requests before anyone leaves.
That is the workflow Pinch Split is built around: no "I'll Venmo you later," no fuzzy amounts, no second round of texts.
Skip "later." Settle now.
Download Pinch Split and split bills before anyone forgets.